Agriculture

Why Black Farmers Are Disappearing: The Truth About Land Loss, Sharecropping & USDA Bias

The history of Black farming in America is marked by resilience and systemic challenges. After the Civil War, many newly freed African Americans aspired to economic independence through Black farming. However, discriminatory policies and practices, such as the broken promise of “40 acres and a mule,” the exploitative sharecropping system, and barriers to land acquisition, significantly hindered these efforts. These historical injustices have contributed to the decline of Black farming, a trend that continues to impact the agricultural landscape today.

The Broken Promise of 40 Acres and a Mule

In 1865, Union General William T. Sherman issued Special Field Order No. 15, allocating 400,000 acres of confiscated Confederate land to newly freed Black families in 40-acre plots. This initiative aimed to provide a foundation for economic self-sufficiency. However, President Andrew Johnson later rescinded this order, returning the land to its former white owners and dashing the hopes of many Black families for land ownership. This reversal eliminated a critical opportunity for building generational wealth within the Black community.

A Closer Look at Sherman’s Field Order No. 15

Sherman’s order was issued on January 16, 1865, during a meeting with 20 Black ministers in Savannah, Georgia. The order was meant to redistribute land along the South Carolina, Georgia, and Florida coasts to freed slaves. Additionally, it provided the possibility of self-governance, allowing Black families to farm independently without white oversight. This was a radical and progressive step toward racial and economic justice. However, after President Johnson rescinded the order, many Black families were forcibly removed, and white landowners regained their properties.

For more details, you can read the full text of Special Field Order No. 15.

The Sharecropping Trap

Deprived of land ownership, many Black Americans became sharecroppers, renting land from white landowners in exchange for a portion of their harvest. This system often trapped Black farmers in a cycle of debt and dependency due to high interest rates, dishonest accounting, and an imbalance of power favoring landowners. Sharecropping closely resembled the conditions of slavery, severely limiting economic mobility for Black families.

Barriers to Land Acquisition

Even those Black farmers who managed to acquire land faced systemic challenges. Discriminatory lending practices, racist policies, and violent land dispossession hindered their ability to maintain and expand their farms. Black landowners were frequently targeted through legal loopholes, fraud, and outright violence, including lynchings and land theft. Additionally, the federal government systematically denied Black farmers access to credit and subsidies that white farmers received, further crippling their agricultural progress.

The Decline of Black Farmers

At the turn of the 20th century, Black farmers owned over 15 million acres of land. However, by the 21st century, that number had declined to less than 3 million acres. Discriminatory policies from the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), foreclosure, and urban migration forced many Black farmers out of agriculture.

Today, Black farmers make up less than 2% of all farmers in the United States, compared to nearly 15% in 1920. The ongoing impact of systemic discrimination, including limited access to capital and resources, continues to challenge Black farmers in ways that their white counterparts do not face.

The Role of Cooperatives

Despite these challenges, Black farmers have historically utilized cooperatives as a means to achieve economic independence and collective action. According to the USDA report “Black Farmers in America, 1865-2000”, various types of cooperatives, including farmer associations, were organized in Black farming communities prior to the 1960s. During the civil rights movement, leaders and organizations adopted an explicit purpose and role for Black cooperatives in pursuing independent farming. These cooperatives provided resources, education, and support, helping Black farmers navigate systemic barriers and advocate for their rights.

Addressing Current Challenges

The fight for Black farming and agricultural equity is ongoing. Efforts such as the Justice for Black Farmers Act seek to address the systemic discrimination Black farmers have faced. Additionally, organizations like the National Black Farmers Association are working to provide resources, education, and legal assistance to help Black farmers thrive.

For assistance and resources, Black farmers can explore the following links:

The decline of Black farming in America is not a coincidence but a result of post-Civil War policies that systematically blocked Black economic independence. From the failure of 40 acres and a mule to the exploitative sharecropping system and limited land acquisition, the barriers Black farmers faced have had lasting effects. Today, reversing this legacy requires policy reform, financial investment, and a commitment to agricultural equity.

    Jasmine

    Jasmine is your everyday multidimensional plant lover and new mama who loves black women and plants so much, she created Black Girls With Gardens! There are 3 things you'll find Jasmine doing separately or simultaneously: 1. Planning for BGWG 2. Plant Shopping 3. Doing both with her baby girl! Go figure!

    Share
    Published by
    Jasmine

    Recent Posts

    Grow With Jas: My 2022 Spring & Summer Garden Plans

    It's approximately 8 weeks until I typically would plant my spring garden outdoors and usually… Read More

    1 year ago

    Small Space Garden: How To Grow In A Small Space Garden

    Having a small space never prevented our ancestors from growing their own food and it… Read More

    3 years ago

    Creating And Cultivating An Ancestral Garden

    I think one of my favorite things I've done so far is created an ancestral… Read More

    3 years ago

    Sustainable Seed Starting Methods and Tips

    It may seem like sustainability is mainstream now, but we all have some recollection of… Read More

    3 years ago

    How To Plant Garlic For Your Biggest Harvest

    How To Plant Garlic Growing garlic is fairly easy - it's literally a "plant and… Read More

    3 years ago

    Grow With Jas: My 2021 Fall Gardening Plans & Updates

    Hello Family! I can't believe I'm already considering my 2021 fall garden, well honestly thinking… Read More

    4 years ago